POSTS

24 leading scholars in the field write CUNY Chancellor Matthew Goldstein denouncing the denial of tenure (11/12)

Jerry Sternstein examines "academic freedom and the academic left"

Albert Hall fears that the decision shows how Brooklyn College is less interested in education than in nurturing "dim lights" (12/31)

History News Network publishes a first-person recapitulation on why the college denied tenure

Ted Burrows and Stuart Schaar organize a response by the college's department chairs

Jerry Sternstein, former department member and PSC grievance counselor, critiques the Burrows post

Yehuda Katz posts the Student Government resolution deeming the denial of tenure a violation of the BC students' bill of rights guarantee of a "quality education"

Figures from around the country denounce the decision:

bullet

Milton Rosenberg

bullet

G. Swanson

bullet

Ralph Luker

bullet

Clayton Cramer

bullet

John Fought

bullet

Richard Henry Morgan

bullet

William Stepp

bullet

Thomas Gunn

Leonard Gordon and Renate Bridenthal debate the meaning of quality in the History Department, two chairs defend their decision, and Nancy Romer says criticizing an unbalanced teach-in was taking "potshots"

Jerry Sternstein, meanwhile, dissects what he terms "the most corrupted tenure review process I have ever come across"

In response to the Post story, an anonymous figure claiming access to inside information defends the History Department chairman

The anonymous poster is quickly rebutted, by:

bullet

Paula Fichtner

bullet

Jerry Sternstein, on substantive grounds (twice)

bullet

Leonard Gordon

Students discuss the reasons they favor tenure and critique the comments of the anonymous poster:

bullet

Dan Weininger

bullet

Brad Appell

bullet

Jenna Schlanger

bullet

Christine Sciascia